Threat 1: Equal Capital Raise Access
Shareholders are usually those who have backed the company through thick and thin, so making sure they are treated fairly at key dilutionary events is very important. Indeed, most growth companies will require additional funding, but ensuring that existing shareholders receive priority to maintain their ownership percentage (or even increase it) is a highly desirable threat in a company.
Altech has demonstrated strong respect for shareholders at the point of capital raises, ensuring that they are prioritised for follow on investment. If we examine their various capital raising programs across the last 36 months, we can see that each time, the company has offered shareholders a way to participate.
- 17 July 2023: $3m placement + $12.8m 1:8 entitlement offer at $0.07 per share. Link
- 2 December 2021: $8.1m placement + $4m SPP at $0.107 per share. Link
- 9 November 2020: $14.5m 2:5 entitlement offer at $0.04 per share. Link
The raise targets used above may differ from the actual outcome based on shortfalls. More on this effect below.
Not only does the involvement of shareholders lower the cost of capital raised, it also drastically reduces the dilutionary impact on shareholders. Let's examine how the ownership percentages could differ if the company chose to exclude existing shareholders instead.
Date
Pre-raise shareholding
Post raise shareholding (full take-up)
ATC SOI (post raise actual)
Ownership
8 November 2020
1,000,000
-
908,336,970
0.110%
November 2020 raise
1,000,000
1,400,000
1,224,058,690
0.114%
December 2021 raise
1,400,000
1,680,374
1,365,376,840
0.123%
July 2023 raise
1,680,374
1,890,421
1,646,183,030
0.115%
As we can see, the facilitation of SPP and entitlement offers by Altech means that shareholders are not meaningfully diluted should they take up most of their entitlement. Conversely, if each raise excluded existing shareholders, this example shareholder would only have a 0.061% ownership as of the most recent raise, a material dilution outcome.
About equal capital raise access
Threat 2: Investor Transparency
Altech has done a great job at maintaining transparency throughout the past 12-24 months. This has coincided with a period of rapid evolution as the company pivoted from a HPA company (via their Johor plant) to a German focused battery technology company. This understandably may have caused a degree of confusion among investors so maintaining absolute transparency is important.
The first type of transparency we can examine is the proactive type - information and materials that the company is releasing on its own accord with the intent of keeping investors as informed as possible. In Altech's case, the development of their Sodium Alumina Solid State Batteries, or CERENERGY, was the primary focus. Since announcing this JV in September 2023, the company has released a total of 10 announcements concerning the progress of the CERENERGY project.
Date
Announcement
Link
14 Sep 2022
Altech - to commercialise 100MWh sodium alumina solid state batteries for grid storage
26 Oct 2022
Appointment of Leader as Lead Engineering for CERENERGY project
7 Nov 2022
Altech launches CERENERGY 60KWh (ABS60) battery pack desin
25 Jan 2023
Altech - Update of CERENERGY battery project
29 Mar 2023
Altech - Launch of CERENERGY 1.0MWh Gridpack design
14 Apr 2023
Altech - Progress update Silumina anodes pilot plant
9 May 2023
Altech - Two 60KWh Battery pack prototypes in production
13 Jun 2023
Altech - CERENERGY proposed battery specifications
3 Jul 2023
Altech - CERNERGY battery project suppliers confirmed
11 Jul 2023
Altech - CERENERGY 50% greenhouse gasses of lithium battery
These activity updates exclude any presentation, video, or educational content that was used to supplement this.Next, we can see a reactive form for transparency. This usually concerns how open a company is to receiving investor queries, both positive and negative, and responding in a timely manner. Typically this can be in the form of webinars, Q&A sessions, and open forum discussion. Altech has implemented a helpful Q&A platform to achieve this:
This is highly encouraging to see and the mix of proactive and reactive actions to drive transparency makes this a compelling threat for Altech.
About investor transparency
Threat 3: Setting goals
From the initial announcement of the 100MWh CERENERGY battery project, the company has outlined a set of goals to achieve this. As with any major project development, there are numerous parts to the wider system and it is important to examine how well a company can set goals and meet them.
The first goal that was announced on 31st Oct 2021 (
link) was the JV intention to plan for a Bankable Feasibility Study for train 1 (100MWh) plant.
Then in the December 2022 quarterly report and March 2023 presentation, the company reiterated the:
- DFS was underway
- Meeting with financiers; and
- Production of test units
- Early stage off-take discussions
These goals outlined are all outstanding at the time of writing (26 Aug) as the company continues to push ahead with project development. The company reiterated that 2 (instead of 1) 60KWh battery packs remains under fabrication.
Although no specific timelines have been set for any of these, the company has proven themselves to be fast moving.
About setting goals